I think we’d all agree that schools are educational institutions. Teachers instruct, and students learn. At least that’s what’s supposed to happen, right? Unfortunately, that’s not always the case.

Remember the old saying, “What gets measured, gets done”? There are plenty of examples of this in education. For instance, teachers may not focus on writing out their lesson plans if principals don’t require them to be submitted for review each week. It happens in the “real” world, as well. What the supervisor monitors is what the employees pay attention to.

A recent article by Bent Meier Sorenson, Professor in Philosophy and Business at Copenhagen Business School, makes a bold statement about the current state of affairs in today’s institutions of higher learning:

Why did he come to this conclusion? Because, he says, universities measure student satisfaction – through student satisfaction surveys – while ignoring typical student learning indicators. Sorenson explains that there are plenty of ways to measure learning, but when we do, the results aren’t pretty.

For example, one long-term, comprehensive study found that 45% of students demonstrated no significant growth in skill (to include critical thinking, complex reasoning, and writing) during their first two years of college (Arum & Roksa, 2010). Given these abysmal results, our universities would, naturally, prefer to pay attention to other measures of success.

You’ve no doubt followed the recent news reports – college students make unreasonable demands and administrators cave. Cafeteria doesn’t serve sushi? Protest! Instructor holds an exam on protest day? Fire the bum! University President backs the teacher? He must resign! Ok, ok…maybe I’m being a little facetious, but it certainly seems as though student learning often takes a back seat to student comfort.

We create “safe spaces,” where students are protected from hearing anything that runs counter to their own point of view, rather than encourage thoughtful debate. How can students develop a value system of their own if they don’t understand (or even have a chance to hear) from all sides? As I mentioned in last week’s blog – diversity is a good thing! We must appreciate all points of view in order to solidify our own stance.

More and more frequently, the evaluations – and pay – of college professors (those hired to teach) are dependent on student satisfaction surveys – not learning! Here’s the rub – learning is difficult, uncomfortable, and sometimes even painful! So, when colleges focus on the key drivers of learning (painful stimuli), student satisfaction tends to decline. Imagine that!

Human beings are wired to avoid pain. I get it! Unfortunately, growth requires some level of pain. Pain avoidance simply sets us up for future failure.

Yet, we continue to shield our students, our children, from the pain of living and growing, preventing them from reaching adulthood with the skills necessary to survive and succeed! In my opinion, we do our students a severe disservice when we obsess over their happiness and comfort level. As Sorenson candidly describes,

“Hospitals measure morbidity and mortality. Corporations measure revenue and profit. Governments measure unemployment and gross domestic product. But universities don’t measure learning. As long as universities continue to measure satisfaction but not learning, the downward spiral of lower expectations, less hard work and less learning will continue.”

If we truly care about our students’ well-being, we must not prevent their growing pains. For it is in these early trials and tribulations that they develop the internal fortitude to withstand the slings and arrows of life.

Written by : drallisonbrown

Subscribe To My Newsletter

BE NOTIFIED ABOUT BOOK SIGNING TOUR DATES

Donec fringilla nunc eu turpis dignissim, at euismod sapien tincidunt.

7 Comments

  1. Lisa Orchard September 30, 2017 at 9:13 am - Reply

    Great post! I wasn’t aware this was going on in our universities. Wow. Times have surely changed!

  2. Lisa Orchard September 30, 2017 at 9:14 am - Reply

    Great post! I didn’t know this was happening in our universities! Times have definitely changed!

    • drallisonbrown September 30, 2017 at 8:37 pm - Reply

      Thanks Lisa! As a former adjunct instructor, I can corroborate this. Many of my students expected an A for simply “doing” the assignment. When they didn’t earn the grade they expected, they would retaliate in the evaluations at the end of the term. Luckily, there were still enough students who appreciated the rigor and high expectations. I was also fortunate to work for a school that backed its teachers.

  3. Claire October 15, 2017 at 10:12 am - Reply

    Hurray for common sense! Great post which, with 2 sons at uni, I can definitely relate to. In the area that we live far too many adolescents are leaving school having been wrapped in cotton wool and with no sense of being street wise. My daughter and friends currenlty have their German exchange partners here – interesting to watch which parents allow their 15/16 year olds “out” to use public transport and arrange their own days, or those who need to be involved at every turn. As you say, without a few trials and tribulations they cannot truly grow. x (BTW we had 16 of the teens here last night – our daughter is certainly growing up and finding her hostess side!!)

    • drallisonbrown October 15, 2017 at 11:15 am - Reply

      Thanks for your comments, Claire! I can relate to what you’ve described, as we have hosted 10 exchange students from all parts of Europe (the majority from Germany). It does seem that, here in the US, we coddle our children much more than the Europeans. I think we are also more prone to lawsuits here, which has fueled a sense of entitlement and a penchant for blaming others.

  4. Diana October 15, 2017 at 12:59 pm - Reply

    As a parent of the millennial generation, we have raised our young to believe that they can have anything in life they want. That is probably why they are known as the entitled generation. So why wouldn’t they think they can have satisfaction instead of doing the work? Loved this post :)

    • drallisonbrown October 15, 2017 at 2:13 pm - Reply

      Thanks, Diana! You are right, we told them they could have anything, but we left out the part about earning it :)

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.