Guess what? There is a nationwide teacher shortage.

Surprised?

I’m not. I’m not the least bit surprised, because I AM an educator. But all those non-educator types – you know, the politicians, the reporters, the educational philanthropists – they seem quite surprised. They even write articles about teacher shortages, wondering what they can do to boost enrollment in teacher education programs!

These are the same people who create foundations and think tanks designed to make educational decisions without consulting educators first! Why? Because they know better! They know better than the classroom teacher what it takes to motivate a child, to corral a bunch of excited 3rd graders, to prevent the next dropout, to teach a recent immigrant Algebra in a non-native language. They are smarter and wiser and more patient than those of us in the trenches. And yet, they are completely baffled by high teacher attrition and graduates who eschew careers in education.

Before you misinterpret my cynicism, I offer this disclaimer. I LOVE my job! I can’t imagine doing anything else! Being an educator was a lifelong dream of mine; I smile the minute I step foot on my campus! That being said, I would not advise my daughter (or my son, if he were interested) to follow in my footsteps.

Why not? Well, there are lots of reasons, really. But, they all boil down into one general theme: educators are given all the responsibility but none of the resources. Case in point: I recently read an article about a teacher panhandling in Oklahoma – for school supplies! This woman stood on a busy street with a sign trying to raise money for her classroom. Otherwise, the supplies would come out of her own pocket….again. Interviewed for the article, the Tulsa Public Schools superintendent, Deborah Gist, acknowledged the budget cuts, reiterating that teachers in Oklahoma have been hit particularly hard. Do you mean to tell me that the Tulsa school superintendent was not sufficiently embarrassed by the sight of one of her own teachers begging on the street, that she agreed to be interviewed?

How does this not mortify every single American citizen? Instead, this teacher is filmed laughing and smiling, waving at passing cars, while the reporter acts like this is perfectly normal – as if there is absolutely nothing wrong with begging for school supplies! To add insult to injury, the teacher serves low income students, who typically suffer disproportionately when money is tight. Don’t her students deserve better? Doesn’t the teacher deserve better?

The kicker is, this teacher will be held accountable (ahhh…accountability – the new buzz word for “data we can use to blame teachers”) for student outcomes when ALL of the variables except one (her teaching) are beyond her control. For example:

Educators don’t control where a student lives: I have had students who lived in the family car, in a hotel, doubled up with friends and relatives, and in a neighborhood where gunfire was their “lullaby.”

Educators don’t control what a student eats: Some students come to school hungry and may not even eat on weekends, most do not eat family dinner together, and a good number of students are addicted to sugar and/or caffeine (which causes them to be edgy, hyper, and irritable, and then crash).

Educators don’t control what happens from birth to age 5: Many students enter Kindergarten or first grade without basic skills – they don’t know their numbers or letters, they have no social skills (like sharing or taking turns), they have poor eye-hand coordination, and they haven’t been read to.

There are lots of other variables that are out of our control, not the least of which include whether the student gets enough sleep, has the time and place to complete homework, studies before exams, has access to a computer and/or internet….you get the picture.

A study in The Urban Review entitled “Why Bright Students Won’t Teach,” by Barnett Berry revealed at least one surprising result – salary wasn’t one of the primary (de)motivators. Instead, graduates cited “frustrating working conditions, bureaucratic requirements, the lack of professional control, and few opportunities for intellectual growth.” The other surprise is that this article was published in 1986. Sadly, not much has changed in the 30 years since then.

The bottom line is that educators are expected to be miracle workers – to (successfully) teach, love, protect, support, guide, and discipline their charges – but they are, essentially, expected to do so with one arm tied behind their back. As Robert Fulghum said, “It will be a great day when our schools have all the money they need, and our Air Force has to have a bake sale to buy a bomber.”

He’s right, but it’s not just about the money. It’s about the respect.

Written by : drallisonbrown

Subscribe To My Newsletter

BE NOTIFIED ABOUT BOOK SIGNING TOUR DATES

Donec fringilla nunc eu turpis dignissim, at euismod sapien tincidunt.

9 Comments

  1. Denzil September 13, 2017 at 1:11 am - Reply

    Well said Allison. The under-funding, under-resourcing and under-appreciation of teachers is certainly not limited to the US. The UK “experts” have also recently expressed surprise at dwindling teacher numbers. Here in Belgium, the pressure put on newly qualified teachers can in many cases by overwhelming. I don’t understand and probably never will why professions like teaching and nursing are not given the respect and salaries commensurate with their responsibilities.

    • drallisonbrown September 13, 2017 at 7:13 am - Reply

      Denzil, thank you for sharing what’s happening across the pond. Unfortunately, we keep putting Band-Aids on a broken system. I think it would really take a major overhaul to make things better; one that we aren’t really ready to commit to.

  2. Hanna September 21, 2017 at 10:16 am - Reply

    Great analysis Allison. Teaching is sadly a thankless job. As a society the way we have structured it as you mentioned is really disgraceful the lack of resources available. It should be one of the most well respected fields/careers. Is this just in the US or worldwide? I have looked into what the education system is like in other countries that have all public education subsidized including higher education.

    • drallisonbrown September 21, 2017 at 9:59 pm - Reply

      Thanks for commenting Hanna. I’ve heard from some bloggers in the UK that things are pretty sad there, as well.

  3. Katie September 28, 2017 at 10:45 am - Reply

    Girl, PREACH ????

  4. Angela Noel May 3, 2018 at 7:50 am - Reply

    Allison, I’ve been thinking a lot on education lately. Mostly about how privileged I am and how sucky it is that we as a country don’t value one of our most precious resources–our children and the people who teach them.
    I have yet to meet a “lazy” teacher. I have yet to meet someone who doesn’t care about his or her students with the kind of passion some parents can’t even muster. And yet we make it so hard for them.
    I struggle to determine what I can do to help beyond money donations and voting for school referendums. What are your ideas?

    • drallisonbrown May 3, 2018 at 11:04 am - Reply

      Angela, there have been some really good articles that have described historically, how and why (in the US) teaching became primarily a female profession, at which point it seemed to lose some respectability within society. This lack of respect for the profession is now ingrained in the fabric of our society, so it will take some time and effort to overcome. Because teachers, who again are mostly female, tend to be less aggressive or less willing to stand up for themselves, we have allowed these abuses to continue. It appears as though we have finally reached our breaking point, and we are starting to stand up for ourselves. The sad thing is, the decision-makers are probably just acquiescing to get kids back in the classroom. It doesn’t mean that they are changing their opinion about educators. I have read many comments from the public that claim teachers are demanding things that we really don’t deserve. Long story short, I don’t have an easy answer. Everything falls at the feet of the educator. We heap responsibilities and accountability on them, and then turn around and say they don’t deserve higher pay or secure retirement benefits. It confounds me.

    • drallisonbrown May 3, 2018 at 9:44 pm - Reply

      Coincidentally, not even an hour after responding to you, I read another great opinion piece explaining how to improve the education system in America, by “elevating the status of public school teachers and attracting our most motivated and talented citizens into classrooms on a long-term basis.” Hmmmm, sounds familiar! Here is the full article: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ryancraig/2018/05/03/the-real-cruelty-of-college-admissions/#369a0f1a5fe6

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.